So for my poetry essay I wrote two different versions. One was the one I turned in, and the second one was the one I actually kinda liked more, but everybody who read it said not to turn it in because it was a political analysis instead of a literary analysis. But I wrote it at a two a.m. on a Saturday, so I was a tad proud of it. I did the Introduction to Poetry by Billy Collins.
Billy Collins Poem:
I ask them to take a poem
and hold it up to the light
like a color slide
or press an ear against its hive.
I say drop a mouse into a poem
and watch him probe his way out,
or walk inside the poem's room
and feel the walls for a light switch.
I want them to waterski
across the surface of a poem
waving at the author's name on the shore.
But all they want to do
is tie the poem to a chair with rope
and torture a confession out of it.
They begin beating it with a hose
to find out what it really means.
Essay:
Born
in the 1940's, Billy Collins was immersed into the horrid treat of the
aftermath of War World Two through the privileged white supremacy point of view.
These events include everlasting hatred towards the Japanese and Europe's
inability to acknowledge their actions towards the Jews. Though Collins is
greatly dismissed as only a woeful poet, Collins uses his writing in order to
release his political views upon the world and revealing the world's inhumane
actions. In his poem "Introduction Of Poetry" Collins integrates his
opinions and knowledge of War World Two in which most Americans, at that time,
ignored, through his gift in writing.
Collins reveals the unethical actions of War World Two by paralleling
the senile events against the misunderstood feelings projected towards poetry
through symbolism and allusions.
In the first stanza, the speaker addresses the ignorance
taken upon in American society. The speaker says, "I ask them to take a
poem/ and hold it up to the light/ like a color slide". A poem, which the
speaker uses as the large analogy in the poem, is created by words that is only
fathomed by past experiences and ideas. During the era the speaker is
illustrating about, majority of the experiences and ideas were still reflecting
upon the war, including racism, prejudices, and abuse towards ethnic groups
such as the Japanese and Jews. The speaker then commands to hold their actions towards
the light, so that the hatred they hide in the dark will be revealed and the
audience will be forced to confront the unfair prejudices that made up society
at that time. Afterwards, the speaker suggests that they hold it up "like
a color shade", or in a view that isn't seen as black and white, in order
to universally understand the common emotions and similarities within the
ethnic groups. For example, a color shade could be used as a view of children, revealing the innocence and
purity that rests in all ethnic groups.
In simpler terms, the first stanza creates an anchor for the speaker's
view of the aftermaths of War World Two, and announces that the speaker will
refuse to sit in silence while the nation refuses to work on the social issues
in America.
The second stanza consists of only one line: or press and ear to against its hive. Not only
does the second stanza hold importance because of its one-lined shift, but also
uses symbolism through body parts and a hive. An ear is commonly used to
symbolize the act of hearing, but it can also symbolize an individual's level
of ignorance. A hive, on the other hand, is technically a closed off area where
bees, which live in communities, raise their young. The speaker, in all,
addresses that the level of ignorance that will be passed on for generations if
individuals refuse to acknowledge their words said in society. If their
prejudices against minorities continue, the speaker says through symbolism, it will
destroy the future generation's morality, if people continue to ignore the
importance of words spoken in society.
The third and fourth stanza creates a question given to
society and its leaders. How will the nation continue being "great",
if individuals and leaders in the country refuse to see the impact prejudices
affect on nations? The speaker says in the poem, "I say drop a mouse into
a poem/ and watch him probe his way out/ or walk inside the poem's room/ and
feel the walls for a light switch". Spiritually, a mouse represents
scrutiny. The speaker suggests that an individual who holds power in the
speaker's nation, to truly be immersed into a minority's situation, and dare them to be the same
person and hold to the same prejudice views when they find their way back. The
speaker desires for somebody who is prejudice to see the true horrors
minorities have to go through, and still hold to the same prejudice views when
they get "out". Not only that, but the speaker also wishes for the
powerful individual to "feel the walls for a light switch" or to
solve this crucial issue that society refuses to realize. The third and fourth stanza is more than just
a dare, but it is also a way to question power and how effectively a leader
using his/her power in the world if a leader does not understand what every
individual in the country is going through.
The fifth stanza begins with the economical difference
between the majority ethnic groups and the minorities. In the 1940's, the
cliché of a "wealthy suburban family" was starting to become real.
After the war, families were starting to live in neighborhoods, fathers were
coming home from dinner every night, and the women were supposed to adapt to
their gender roles. But towards this typical family, the idea of family
vacations were starting to become a "thing" and other activities that
made a family bond together. A common family activity, if a family had a decent
amount of money, would be going to the beach and waterskiing. Like the speaker
says, "I want them to waterski/across the surface of a poem/waving at the
authors name on the shore". The speaker uses the typical family activity
in order to explain that the cliche idea was an illusion to people with wealth.
Beneath the "surface" there was poverty and abuse that destroyed
families of minorities, contrasting to the perfect majority ethnic family. The
economical stand point that the speaker is stating is that families with money
were the ones who were blind to those who did not have it. Instead of seeing
beyond their wealth and what it meant towards the country, they only saw the
opportunities they were given as families in order to dismiss the evils in
America. At the end of the stanza the speaker reintroduces the parallel between
the country and a poem and says, "waving at the author's name on the
shore" or acknowledging the politicians who have let this economical
difference occur.
In the last two stanzas, the speaker reminds the audience
what had happened to the ethnic groups during the war, in order to highlight
the majority's brutality. In the sixth stanza,
the speaker addresses the actions inflicted on the Japanese during the war,
"But all they want to do/ is tie the poem to a chair with a rope/and
torture a confession out of it". The speaker exclaims that America had
unfairly accused the Japanese of being spies, and then, in fear and cowardice,
shoved them into camps in order to be starved and abused. The speaker also
implies that though the Allies won the war, America was so emotionally
humiliated they would rather blame it on the Japanese-Americans who had done
nothing, rather than take responsibility for their faults. Now that the war is
over, the speaker claims that the majorities who had done this in the first
place would gladly do it again because their ability to show sympathy is
extinct.
The speaker's last line inhabits not just America's
prejudice, but Europe's as well. The speaker says, talking about all of the
murdered Jews in the Holocaust, who had fallen to ultimate torture during the
war, "They begin beating it with a hose/to find out what it really
means". A hose is a tool that exerts water towards the ground. In other
words, the speaker mocks them by saying that Europe is finally seeing, as they
wash away the blood they had spilled on the ground, all the innocent corpses that had been hidden in concentration
camps. Unlike Americans, Europe is too late to recover what they had lost, so
the only thing they can do is learn about the sins they had committed. The
further they uncover, the more the nations start to see how horrifying they really
are.